Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Robin Dumler's avatar

Sorry, all I've got to say is thanks a lot, stupid fucking Trump & partners in crime. I hope 2026 kicks you in the ass and elsewhere, because that's where we're aiming.

Steve's avatar

I wouldn’t advertise Mamdani, I’d recommend being mum about him, at least till after the midterms.

He calls himself a social Democrat, but Bernie calls himself that now too, and so does AOC, etc. but we all know that they previously called themselves socialist. At least Bernie did, and they touted him.

Advertising him and them will not help in the midterms.

Of course those running in parochial districts like Brooklyn or small democratic areas of Republican states like Iowa, they can waive their progressive flags and win. AOC only needs 18,000 votes to win her area. But nationally it’s a big loser.. and we have to think midterms,, that’s national 438 seats. The progressive label would cost Democrats millions of votes. We have to win states that we normally don’t in order to get a super majority, impeach Trump, and put him away where he belongs.

If the progressive label would keep us from doing that, how arrogant do you have to be, to keep waving it in areas that you’re gonna win, but you’ll cause other Democrat to lose, and for Democrats not to win enough seats to get rid of Trump.

Franklin D. Roosevelt was neither a modern “progressive” nor a social democrat.

FDR was a New Deal liberal.

Why FDR was not a social democrat, or a progressive.

FDR rejected this framing outright:

He opposed nationalized healthcare

He did not seek social ownership of industry

He defended capitalism, repeatedly calling his goal its preservation, not replacement

He never identified as a socialist or social democrat

In 1936, FDR explicitly said:

“I am fighting to save capitalism from itself.”

That is fundamentally anti–social democratic in ideology.

Why FDR is often called a progressive

FDR did emerge from the Progressive Era tradition, which emphasized:

• Regulation of monopolies

• Anti-corruption

• Worker protections

• Government intervention to stabilize markets

His New Deal policies reflected this:

• Social Security (insurance model, not welfare)

• Banking regulation (Glass–Steagall)

• Labor protections (NLRA)

• Public works (CCC, WPA)

But even here, FDR differed from modern progressives:

Programs were means-tested or contributoryHe governed pragmatically, not ideologically.

FDR consistently used the term “liberal”, meaning:

• Pro-capitalist

• Pro-democracy

• Pro–regulated markets

• Anti–authoritarian (both fascist and communist)

Progressive is an oxymoron because they’ve been the group that gave the president presidency to the two worst presidents in history. They are very regressive..

What struck me when the new mayor of Miami, congratulations to her for winning the race, but she called herself a progressive, and when I looked at her platform, it was straight liberal democrat, with nothing progressive about it.

Just get rid of the term

16 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?